He's a restless one, Will Oldham. Left to himself he's one of the finest songwriters of recent years. But he's never been able to sit still - constantly refreshing his work through collaborations with the great and sometimes not-so-good. Hooking up with Tortoise was bound to produce one of the more interesting ones. And embarking on a cover versions project promised to make it more listenable than some.

Yes and no. This certainly passes the first test of cover version project -there's very little by way of a straight version. Ok so Mike Watts' It's Expected I'm Gone might just fuzz up over a familiar minuteman bass, but Daniel (yes, that Daniel) is given a breakbeat and post rock twiddling makeover - topped off with a distant transistor radio vocal. Thunder Road likewise wanders far from its source - with a laid back freaky Californian vibe, though one that somehow emphasises the sheer quality of Springsteen's writing in a way that I, at least, had never heard before.

Not everything works - Devo's That's Pep! lacks a bit of, well, pep really. Pep never has been much of a feature of Oldham's voice. Ironically it's the straighter versions that work best - Oldham's voice being distinctive enough to bring something new to a song on its own. Some Say (I Got Devil) stumbles timelessly forwards and Pancho is simply sweet - and neatly contemporary in the time of Brokeback Mountain.

These apart it's not an easy record to get to grips with, but half of it at least rewards your efforts.

What's your view? Comment on the Forum

Other discussions on the SoundsXP forums right now...

Spread the word: Email this article

NAT JOHNSON - Interview

BROKEN FAMILY BAND - Live

SLOW DOWN TALLAHASSEE - Live

WAKE THE PRESIDENT - Live

WAVE PICTURES - Live

SCREAMING TEA PARTY - Live

DARREN HAYMAN - Live

SPEEDMARKET AVENUE - Live

BRAKES - Interview

OF MONTREAL - Live